At first glance, it looks like it came straight out of the Base Setbut surprise
On Save Life, Sisay is saving Gerrard, who is drowning, albeit in a weird fashion, in the pool
Discard payoffs Waste Not (~$7.33) turns every opponent's discard into resources
What puts it behind other ramp cards is that it can only search for basic Forests, so its less useful for mana fixing
Replenish has been closing games outright since day one, and even in the present Modern metagame, Resurgent Belief has shown how powerful mass-reanimating enchantments can be
Perhaps the timing restriction scares people off, but youve got to damper instant speed mass reanimation somehow