The thing that makes it a weaker entry is the fact that (unlike many of the other decks on this list) it doesnt actually contain many competitively viable cards
But keep in mind that if you want to play a Thoughtseize or Metallic Rebuke, the mana can support it (just don't try playing any cards with double-colored mana costs)

Wilds Unknown All Sets Sealed Products Vibes Birb & Pengu Legend of the Lils All Sets Sealed Products Sorcery: Contested Realm Gothic Dragonlord Sealed Products Bo Jackson Battle Arena Tecmo Bowl The Griffey Set Sealed Products Wonders of The First Call of the Stones Existence Sealed Products Flesh and Blood Mastery Pack Warrior Omens of the Third Age All Sets Sealed Products Star Wars: Unlimited Legends of the Force Jump to Lightspeed Sealed Products My Little Pony Friendship Begins Sealed Products CookieRun: Braverse Arena of Glory Age of Heroes and Kingdoms Sealed Products Supplies & More New Supplies Heavy Play Sleeves Deck Boxes Playmats All Supplies Lots & Collections Gift Certificates Digital Products Sell Your Cards Get Started Sell Magic: The Gathering Sell Riftbound Sell Disney Lorcana Sell Flesh and Blood Ship + Sell Events SCG CON Magic RCQ Search SWU Qualifiers Tournament Coverage Community Articles Deck Database MTG 2026 Set Schedule Commander VS The Spike Feeders TARDIS Doctor Who Commander Foil - #187 Magic: The Gathering TARDIS Doctor Who Commander Foil - #187 Magic: The Gathering $0.75 (You save ) Condition: (Required) Near Mint Played Heavily Played Quantity: Decrease Quantity of undefined Increase Quantity of undefined Add to Wish List Create New Wish List Related Products TARDIS Quick view Choose Options $0.29 View Details Start the TARDIS Quick view Out of stock $1.25 Out of Stock Idris, Soul of the TARDIS Quick view Choose Options $0.99 View Details Start the TARDIS Quick view Choose Options $0.29 View Details TARDIS Quick view Out of stock $49.99 Out of Stock Close

Edit: In the meantime, Ravensburger added some more information and helpful videos to their own website
The game has a button dedicated to asking other characters if they want to play, and most of them say yes
In a four player Commander game, Smothering Tithe can easily bag you five or six treasures per turn, and if the other players let the card sit on the table unchallenged, it can easily catapult you to victory